We may earn a commission from links on this page.
I love my Peloton Bike—which I got directly from the at-home fitness giant in 2021—and anyone who knows me will tell you that. As of today, I’m on an 89-day streak of consistent, daily use (though a small portion of that streak is made up of other Peloton offerings, like walking, stretching, and meditation classes).
But just because I’m into it doesn’t mean everyone is. I am, after all, an actual spin teacher, so I’m always trying to take classes, learn new techniques, and stay on top of my game for my own unique reasons. My Peloton, honestly, is just one of many different bikes I use in a given week and have used over the past decade of being dedicated to spinning. Unlike me, many people are looking to get rid of their bikes, treadmills, row machines, and more—whether because they’re back in a gym, they’re upgrading to something better, or they just don’t have the time or desire to work out as much anymore. If you want to get into at-home fitness, let their loss be your gain.
Why fitness equipment resale is a good idea
While we were discussing this post, Lifehacker’s senior health editor Beth Skwarecki made an excellent point: There are simply fewer to buy new Pelotons, given how many are out on the market now and the fact that the Peloton Bike itself hasn’t changed much since its debut. Many of the company’s newer innovations are software-focused, not hardware-focused. You can upgrade your operating system, download Peloton’s apps, and continue to engage with the content, games, and classes it’s still continually rolling out—all with machines that already exist.
If you’re looking for non-Peloton equipment, the argument still stands. Some spin bikes and treadmills have better features than others, but they’re all basically doing the same thing at the end of the day. As long as the thing’s been maintained well, a 15-year-old bike still does exactly what a bike that was built yesterday does. You don’t need a new one to get a good workout.
You can save a lot of money, fight consumerism, and still access a great product by buying used, provided you use a safe, trusted platform to do it. And Peloton agrees: The company announced recently that it’s launching its own resale platform.
Even prior to that, people were buying, selling, and trading not only Peloton equipment, but other at-home fitness machines as well. Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, and other platforms have been awash in these kinds of listings for years.
I’m a proponent of buying used stuff: I love saving money, renewing my wardrobe, and selling my own things to get money to get new—or new-to-me—things. Still, I understand that some people have hangups about owning, wearing, or using items that once belonged to someone else. Break free of the limiting mindset of capitalism, my friend. Save your coins. You can absolutely obtain a quality piece of used equipment that looks and functions similarly a new one.
How to find good used at-home workout equipment
As mentioned, Peloton is getting into the resale game, but the company’s platform is in its nascent stages: Right now, you can only list your own pre-owned Bike, Tread, Row, or branded accessories. In the coming weeks, you’ll be able to buy, but first the marketplace needs to gather inventory.
I don’t recommend using Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist if you’re specifically buying Peloton equipment. There are too many horror stories out there of buyers not being able to log into the devices with their own accounts because the machines are registered to someone else. Some people even report that there are fake bikes and machines on the market.
For equipment that doesn’t require a complex software component, like a regular old spin bike, go ahead and use a person-to-person marketplace if you’re comfortable—provided the seller is communicative, is willing to answer your questions or provide more photos, and, ideally, lets you examine the equipment before you take it home. Use common sense. Bring someone with you, meet in a public place if possible, and be prepared to back out if anything feels off.
If you’re looking for a more formal, managed experience or seeking a Peloton instrument, use a trusted platform that can act as an intermediary and keep everything on the up-and-up. Try Trade My Stuff, an online marketplace at the forefront of at-home gym equipment resale. There, you can get a Peloton, a Bowflex, or even a sauna. The platform offers some security, providing delivery and working with you on the transaction.
With Trade My Stuff, the seller pays a fee—between 10% and 20%, depending on the category of item sold—and the delivery contractor inspects the product at pickup before bringing it to you. You can even ask the delivery team to video call you so you can participate in the inspection before telling them to go ahead and bring it.
Shayne Boyle, a Peloton Bike user who purchased a used treadmill, tells me that his experience was surprisingly robust: The delivery driver traveled hours with the treadmill, even toggling on his location so Boyle could track the machine’s progress to his house. Trade My Stuff offers an optional 12-month warranty to protect the equipment. If anything goes wrong, you’ll get a replacement machine within a week. Yes, you’re paying a delivery fee, but it beats being ghosted by a scammy Craigslist seller.
What to keep in mind when buying used fitness equipment
When you’re buying something used, you have to keep two things in mind: condition and price. Boyle was looking for a Tread, but he wanted it to be near-perfect. He only searched for ones that had been originally purchased in the last year or two, so he was prepared to spend a little more. “For us, price was a big factor, sure, and how old and how used the machine was,” he says.
When I’m using resale apps to shop for a specific accessory or clothing item, I play a bit of a waiting game. I know its retail value, what I’m willing to spend, and the condition the item will likely be in if it aligns with my personal budgeting goals, but I also know there are people out there who just want to get rid of something as fast as they can and may be willing to sell me a piece in great condition for a low price if I just wait it out.
If you want your item to be in top condition, it’ll likely cost you more. If you don’t mind a little wear and tear, you’ll spend less. That’s fine for me when I buy clothes—I’m a savvy stain remover and seamstress—but when you’re considering fitness equipment, exercise caution. A device that doesn’t run right can pose a safety issue for you. The continued function of your knees is worth the extra few hundred dollars you may have to spend to get a spin bike with pedals that don’t jam up.
Don’t forget that Peloton charges $95 to activate used bikes and other equipment. That price is coming down to $45 soon, but it’s still a factor you need to budget for. (On Trade My Stuff, you can use discount code ACTIVATE4FREE to trigger a $95 rebate that will cover the fee.)
No matter what, communicate extensively with your seller. In my experience, if someone is unwilling to send more photos or answer questions, they’re hiding something or otherwise just aren’t great at customer service. Even though you’re paying less than retail, you’re still paying, so you have the right to deal only with sellers who are willing to play ball. Ask for videos, details, and pictures. If you’re getting slow responses or a weird vibe, move on to the next. There are thousands of listings out there.
